February 19, 1942: A Black Stain on American History

  • Share on Tumblr

manzanarNOTE: Today marks the 71st anniversary of FDR signing executive order 9066, which authorized the “indefinite detention” of nearly 150,000 people on American soil.

The order authorized the Secretary of War and the U.S. Army to create military zones “from which any or all persons may be excluded.” The order left who might be excluded to the military’s discretion. When President Franklin D. Roosevelt inked his name to EO9066 on Feb. 19, 1942, it opened the door for the roundup of some 120,000 Japanese-Americans and Japanese citizens living along the west coast of the U.S. and their imprisonment in concentration camps. In addition, between 1,200 and 1,800 people of Japanese descent watched the war from behind barbed wire fences in Hawaii. Of those interned, 62 percent were U.S. citizens. The U.S. government also caged around 11,000 Americans of German ancestry and some 3,000 Italian-Americans.

Today,  people around the country say are saying “never again” – and working to resist the same kind of arbitrary power to detain people with no due process written into the 2012 National defense Authorization Act. Washington  state Senator Bob Hasegawa is one of those people. Following is the story of his family’s personal experience with indefinite detention and what he’s trying to do about it today, originally published on the Daily Caller website.

For most Americans, the debate over indefinite detention provisions written in the National Defense Authorization Act plays out primarily as an academic exercise. The average Joe walking down Main Street U.S.A. simply doesn’t worry about armed government thugs snatching him up, throwing him in the back of a van and hauling him off to some camp somewhere.

But one Washington state senator plunged into the NDAA fray with much more than academic, political or rhetorical interest. For Sen. Bob Hasegawa, indefinite detention without due process is personal.

His family lived it.

Hasegawa’s parents, grandparents, uncles and aunts, along with their entire community, spent three years living in barrack shacks behind barbed wire and armed guards at Minidoka Internment Camp in southern Idaho, not knowing if, or when they would ever get out.

Their crime?

Japanese ancestry.

“While they were constructing the camp, my family lived in horse stalls in the stables at the Puyallup Fairgrounds,” he said. “They were all U.S. citizens.”

The Seattle Democrat was the first member of his family born after internment. The injustice his family endured needs no explanation, but he said the sad legacy of that experience lingers on even today.

“They never talked about it at all,” he said. “It was sort of like a community embarrassment, and they internalized it.”

That shame led to a suppression of Hasegawa’s culture and heritage. His parents rarely spoke Japanese after that. He said they didn’t want the kids to have an accent. They gave their children American sounminidokading names – like Bob.

“They didn’t want anything to be held against us, be it race or ethnicity. They wanted to shield us from that.”

Many Americans write off the danger of indefinite detention powers, arguing they “only apply to terrorists.” Hasegawa bristles at such rhetoric.

“It makes me angry – really angry,” he said with barely contained emotion. “So many presidents gave lip service. When President Gerald Ford finally rescinded EO9066 in 1976, he said, ‘I call upon the American people to affirm with me this American Promise – that we have learned from the tragedy of that long-ago experience forever to treasure liberty and justice for each individual American, and resolve that this kind of action shall never again be repeated.’ Yet, it seems we have to relive these lessons.”

Hasegawa said he often runs into the “it could never happen to me” mentality.

“That makes me think of that German priest’s quote about Nazi Germany. What was his name? He said, ‘There was nobody to speak up for me…’”

The quote Hasegawa references is attributed to Lutheran pastor Martin Niemöller.

“First they came for the communists, and I didn’t speak out because I wasn’t a communist. Then they came for the socialists, and I didn’t speak out because I wasn’t a socialist. Then they came for the trade unionists, and I didn’t speak out because I wasn’t a trade unionist. Then they came for me, and there was no one left to speak for me.”

With his family’s experience motivating him, Hasegawa decided he needed to step up and speak for any future victims of unjust federal force.  On Feb.1, he filed SB 5511 in the Washington Senate. The bill condemns sections of the NDAA allowing for indefinite detention without due process as unconstitutional and includes provisions blocking any such attempts in the Evergreen State. It forbids any state agency cooperation with federal indefinite detention attempts and provides criminal penalties for anybody who tries.

Get the new book today!

Republican Rep. Jason Overstreet sponsored similar legislation in 2012 and filed a House companion bill this session. Overstreet reached out to Hasegawa across the political aisle after learning about his family’s internment during a “Day of Remembrance” in the Washington House last year. Hasegawa said he’s happy that they can work together and form a coalition to protect the Constitution and the Bill of Rights.

Republican Matt Shea signed on as a cosponsor to HB1581. He said he considered it an obligation

“Indefinite detention means that due process is dead,” he said. “State legislators must defend against federal overreach. It is our duty. The oath we take in accordance with Article VI of the U.S. Constitution requires nothing less.”

Washington joins 13 other states considering bills to block NDAA detention within their borders. Virginia Governor Bob McDonnell signed a similar bill into law last year and more than 16 local and county governments have passed resolutions condemning detention without due process.

About Mike Maharrey

Michael Maharrey [send him email] is the Communications Director for the Tenth Amendment Center. He proudly resides in the original home of the Principles of '98 - Kentucky. See his blog archive here and his article archive here. He also maintains the blog, Tenther Gleanings.

Enjoyed This Post?

We cannot succeed without your help, as we will never accept government grants or handouts. Please help us by investing in the Constitution and freedom today!

Enjoyed This Post?
33 comments
Sort: Newest | Oldest
doraflores1234
doraflores1234 like.author.displayName 1 Like

I am wondering where the survivors of Benghazi are.

lamprius
lamprius like.author.displayName like.author.displayName like.author.displayName 3 Like

There were more than Japanese 'relocated.'  My wife's uncle, an Italian chemist (he made cleaning supplies for a living) was 'taken' and couldn't be found for over six months... Finally, his wife found him -- very costly and filed a lawsuit in the Fed Cts to have him released....

PaulYannucci
PaulYannucci

I can understand in one sense why Mr. Hasaguwa would be upset but we didn't ask the Japanese to come and kill our American soldiers either. The president did what he that was right to protect this country.  We were attacked and he reacted to defend this country unlike now where our borders are free range and almost anyone could in. Let me say this I respect all the peopel who supported the United States reguardless of nationalitiy. I think maybe we all learned somwthing from this. As far as I am concerned this country doesn't owe anyone an apology for defendin itself from its agressers.

RedTulie
RedTulie

 @PaulYannucci So you're apparently not aware that EVERY war has been financed by and nursed into being by the effing banksters?  It was OUR government's meddling, provocation and harassment of Japan that finally pushed them to attack at Pearl Harbor.  The ships that were set up like bowling pins for the attacking planes to destroy were an intentional order that the then commander objected to.  Perhaps you need to do some additional research and remember that the history taught to us all has been mainly lies and vital omissions.

PaulYannucci
PaulYannucci

Thats not the history that most of us remember and neither do the veterans that fought in that war.

drewboyy
drewboyy like.author.displayName 1 Like

 @PaulYannucci

 so you wouldnt mind you and your family being detained and shipped to an internment camp if the country of YOUR national origin was involved in a war with the US?

PaulYannucci
PaulYannucci

Obviously you didn't understand what I posted. FDR did what he thought was best at the time. We have come a long way since then but this nation needs to defend itself from all enemies our would you rather be taken over buy another nation which seems to be happening already.

PaulYannucci
PaulYannucci

We need to take a stand that means all of us who believe in the United States and not the New World Order. I am a lifelong Democrat 9/12 Patriot and also a member of the TEA party. I am sorely disapointed in the Democratic party and their willingness to tax us to death all the while our economy is in the toilet and our dollar is losing world spending power.

doraflores1234
doraflores1234

All it takes for evil to exist is for good men to remain silent.

OdellHarwell
OdellHarwell like.author.displayName 1 Like

 @PaulYannucci  I want to think that it won't happen here ever again, but the recent passage of the NDAA legislation and the cancelling of Habius corpus is very disturbing for our future. Especially if you speak out on internet forums or other public media.

PaulYannucci
PaulYannucci

 @DwayneCorrea I served in the military fr 26yrs and was in Desert Storm retired in 95. I was also a police officer for 7yrs. I had to wait until I was 21yrs old to vote and have never missed voting in an election. When we misinformed voters put a person in office that said he would have an open and honest govt. then seals his records doesn't say much about him and the people that voted for him. I ran for town council once lost by one vote. I will most likely run for office again to try to keep the govt. out of our pockets.

DwayneCorrea
DwayneCorrea like.author.displayName like.author.displayName like.author.displayName 3 Like

 @PaulYannucci

 Paul, we already are taken over by foreign interests; international bankers and multi-national corporations own the US governement, you, your property, your children, their children and their children ad infinitum. They control the laws which you must live by, own your unrepayable national debt, suppress dissention via unconstitutional laws, police brutality, and they own the media that tells you what to think, do, how to act and what to buy and buy into. And that is not half of the Orwellian nightmare that US citizens compliance, apathy and ignorance is allowing. News flash, your Constitution is dead in the water unless you and the rest of the disinformed masses stand up and take your country back from these international gangsters.

drewboyy
drewboyy like.author.displayName like.author.displayName like.author.displayName 3 Like

 @PaulYannucci

 i believe "we" are in the process of learning. which is why im thankful for this site and many others like it. i have so many friends and family that have no idea what is being done within their own borders, by those who were sworn to protect them and their rights. they are beginning to see the light, thanks to those brave enough to speak out against this evil. unfortunately, i believe it can happen, and will...if we let them.

PaulYannucci
PaulYannucci

No I would not like it but I would have to accept it by no choice of my own. But as I said we have come a long way since then and I don't think any of us will have to see this happen again. As I said before I understand why FDR did what he did at that time. They went a little to far as we also had Japanese that were legal Americans fighting in the war with us. I hope we have learned from what happened but at  the rate we are going now I somehow doubt it. 

drewboyy
drewboyy like.author.displayName like.author.displayName 2 Like

 @PaulYannucci

 i understand clearly what you posted. i posed a question to you which has not been answered. would you be alright with you and your family being imprisoned by the US government based on your nationality?

EmilieJanicki
EmilieJanicki like.author.displayName like.author.displayName 2 Like

We, as the people, for whom the Constitution was written for, must stop ignoring the drastic, power hungry, unlawful, and individuality condemnation laws that are quickly being passed. We must stand up for our rights to chose our lives and for other citizens to have those same rights. If we do not speak up and spread acknowledgment of these unconstitutional laws being accepted to others, the government will continue to grow and continue to seek more power of the individual and minorities, leaving us with eventually no rights at all, not even to protect ourselves or our loved ones.

PaulYannucci
PaulYannucci like.author.displayName 1 Like

If they earn the right to be here legally. My grandparents and my mom earned their way here. They didn't come illegally like the twelve million illegals we have now taking jobs and getting insurance that legal Americans cn't even get.

JennieWalsh
JennieWalsh like.author.displayName 1 Like

How very fragile liberty is against the tireless power-mongering tyrants who want to own and control everyone and everything. 

mogul264
mogul264 like.author.displayName 1 Like

 @JennieWalsh Liberty itself isn't so fragile, but like a buffalo, surround it with enough wolves, and given enough time to wear it down, and the buffalo WILL fall! Unfortunately, the wolfpack is growing daily, with the coyotes waiting until the wolves are finished!

 

Now substitute Liberty, our world enemies, and the commiecrats for the buffalo, the wolfpack, and the coyotes, and you'll see our problem! Time is on THEIR side! We need more brave buffalo defenders to help!

Michael Murray
Michael Murray

“The smallest minority on earth is the individual. Those who deny individual rights cannot claim to be defenders of minorities.” ― Ayn Rand

amyswhimzyfl
amyswhimzyfl

I lost my maternal heritage because her family emigrated to the USA about 1907 from Germany. She wouldn't acknowledge her ancestry during WW2. I was born in 1946 but she still kept mum about relations in E Germany. There were detainee camps there in NY. My loss!

dover
dover

Then how come he's a democ-RAT??

Mike Maharrey
Mike Maharrey moderator like.author.displayName 1 Like

 @dover Republicans support this detention garbage too. This is not a partisan issue.

Bill Coleman
Bill Coleman

At first glance, NDAA appears to be a good idea IF it was in fact Constitutional and we lived in a "perfect world" with the federal tiger secured within the cage designed for it by the states via the Constitution. I do hope that there are Constitutional laws that can be used and/or passed to protect citizens and defend the Constitution from people who have loyalty to causes that are incompatible with the Constitution and are threats to citizens and the Constitution. So far this hope appears to just that without very much satisfaction.

rick abney
rick abney

I can see down the road when the much vaunted, heralded time comes when white europeans become a minority, the Obama of that happy day decides for whatever reason, some real or imagined threat, that particular minority is a threat. This will defintely happen. Right now, it's unfashionable to be a european, straight male. Some day soon, it may become dangerous. As a minority, what will we do? What could the Japanese do? The white, european, straight male is the Japanese of the future.

Michael Boldin
Michael Boldin moderator like.author.displayName like.author.displayName 2 Like

 @rick abney It's far less about WHO,  - who cares about whether the person attacked is white, black, asian - or anything in between.  The concern is that bad people love power - and when the people allow them great power, eventually someone is going to use it against you.

WilliamSchooler
WilliamSchooler

@Michael Boldin

NO bad people don’t love power, ignorant people love power and the fact is none of them are any different than you. They are going to learn their lessons the same way you learn yours. We were all ignorant once or twice or many times, some of us have accepted we must learn to grow, some think you learn by words in books without life lessons. This is not the case and all will learn regardless of how big they huff and puff their chest, Ignorance shall not prevail because the examples of intelligence far out shines the ignorant.

 

This country is filled with black stains we have all agreed to or they just would not be, money is our biggest and yes I said OUR, unless of course you have stopped using it.

 

DavidWelsh
DavidWelsh

Along that same track, that is why I am against crimes labeled as "hate crimes."  I could care less whether someone burned down my house because of my religion, looks, or just for no reason al all except to be stupid. My garage burns just the same regardless of motivation. And the culprit needs to be brought to justice for what he did. Pretty simple. Japanese Americans were interned against their will and FDR--the hero of many--acted unconstitutionally against them. What FDR did could easily be labeled as a "hate crime" in modern jurisprudence, but so what? People were screwed over big time. FDR broke the law and got away with it. It should never be repeated. That's all that matters. Imperial presidents--starting with Lincoln--and lapdog courts and media have largely been responsible for breaches in constitutional practice.

Trackbacks

  1. [...] by Mike Maharrey, TenthAmendmentCenter.com: [...]

  2. [...] however, proves that it can in fact happen here. The Tenth Amendment Center reminds us of this fact with a look back to 71 years ago today, when Franklin Delano Roosevelt [...]

  3. [...] February 20, 2013 Mike Maharrey 2/19/2013 Source ….. [...]

  4. [...] by Connor Boyack, TenthAmendmentCenter.com: [...]

  5. [...] The moral of the story is: don’t be a member of any minority group the state may at some future point oppress. Or, get rid of the state. Read the rest of his article here. [...]

  6. [...] February 18, 1942: A Black Stain on American History (tenthamendmentcenter.com) [...]

  7. [...] February 18, 1942: A Black Stain on American History (tenthamendmentcenter.com) [...]